You are here
LAKE TAHOE, Nev. -- A California jury told oil companies to pay $69 million to fix the damage MTBE caused to groundwater at South Shore. But will they have to pay for cleanup anywhere else?
The gasoline additive, which is banned at the Lake Tahoe Basin, has become a topic of debate as part of an energy bill working its way through Congress. Several lawmakers have argued that oil companies should not be held responsible to pay cleanup costs associated with the product. The bill proposes a national ban on the additive while creating incentives to increase the production of ethanol, a corn-based fuel additive that also is water soluble, according to the Tahoe (Nev.) Daily Tribune.
Rep. Joe Barton (R-Texas) and Rep. Billy Tauzin (R-La.), the House Energy Conference chairman, argued that if a nationwide ban of the additive is passed, MTBE makers should be given a liability waiver against lawsuits arising from MTBE contamination of water supplies.
"Why should the taxpayers pay for this cleanup?" asked Sen. Harry Reid (D-Nev.)
Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle (D-S.D.) has said he will not support an energy bill that includes MTBE liability relief, according to a report by the Environmental & Energy Daily.
In August, after years of legal battle, the South Tahoe Public Utility District was awarded $69 million from oil companies to fix damage done to its water system. The money, whittled down to $35 million after covering attorney fees and district work already done to clean up MTBE at the South Shore, was awarded after a jury determined the additive is a defective product. The district shut down 12 of its 34 water wells in 1998 because trace amounts of the additive were detected in eight of its wells.
About $1.5 million of the awarded money has already been spent on the installation of an innovative water treatment system in Meyers, Nev. The district says there is no way to determine how long it will take to treat its water. A site at Rockaway, N.J., has been treating MTBE-laced water for 20 years and the chemical is still present, a Meyers official said.
MTBE was introduced to gasoline in the 1990s to reduce emissions. Water experts discovered the chemical, a suspected carcinogen, moved through groundwater fast, leaving it smelling like turpentine and unsafe to drink. In April 2000, the El Dorado County portion of Lake Tahoe Basin became the first area in the country to ban MTBE.