Stagnito Media Convenienece Store News Convenienece Store News Single Store Owner Progressive Grocer The Gourmet Retailer Progressive Grocer Store Brands Retail Leader  
 
Nov 07, 2011

Judge Blocks New Graphic Cigarette Warning Labels

PrintJudge Blocks New Graphic Cigarette Warning Labels  

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Tobacco companies have won the first round in their fight against the new graphic cigarette warning labels that are set to go into effect next September.

In a ruling this morning, U.S. District Judge Richard Leon granted a temporary injunction blocking the rules requiring the new warning labels that use graphic images. Leon's decision came as he determined that the tobacco companies -- namely R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co., Lorillard Inc., Commonwealth Brands Inc. and Liggett Group LLC -- would likely win their lawsuit challenging the Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) requirement as unconstitutional, according to a report by Reuters.

"We are pleased with the judge's ruling and look forward to the court's final resolution of this case," an R.J. Reynolds spokesperson told CSNews Online.

The FDA approved the nine warnings -- a combination of text and graphic photographs -- in June, and mandated that the new labels must be depicted on all cigarette packs and advertising by September 2012.

As a result, the four tobacco companies took up a legal challenge on the grounds that the new warnings violated the free speech clause of the First Amendment. They contended it was unconstitutional to force tobacco companies to disseminate the government’s anti-smoking message, as CSNews Online reported in August.

However, in response to the suit, the FDA said the public interest in conveying the dangers of smoking outweighs the companies' free speech rights. The FDA also pointed out that Congress gave it the authority to require the new labels because existing warnings dating to 1984 were going unnoticed and health warnings weren't being conveyed effectively.

The tobacco companies gained support in September when two advertising groups, the Association of National Advertisers and the American Advertising Federation, filed briefs in the suit. The groups argued that the labels infringe on commercial free speech and could lead to further government intrusion if left unchallenged.

Floyd Abrams, a partner in the New York law firm of Cahill Gordon & Reindel, who is representing Lorillard, said: "Today's ruling reaffirms fundamental First Amendment principles by rejecting the notion that the government may require those who sell lawful products to adults to urge current and prospective purchasers not to purchase those products."

 








Find Reports & Data

CSNews' 2011 Realities of the Aisle Consumer Study

Consumers are shopping convenience stores slightly more often than they were a year ago, but the nation’s economic doldrums continue to be a drag on spending, according to Convenience Store News’ annual consumer study – Realities of the Aisle 2011.

CSNEWS 2011 Foodservice Study

After reporting a 6.1-percent sales increase in 2010, convenience store retailers expect to generate increased sales and profits from their foodservice operations this year.

CSNews' 2011 Industry Report Study

The convenience store industry had a good year last year. The 13.5 percent total industrywide sales increase was a big improvement over the more than 20-percentage point drop in 2009.

CSNews 2011 New Products Scorecard

The success rates for new items introduced to the convenience store industry last year were down in all seven major product categories tracked in the Convenience Store News New Product Scorecard, but retailers nevertheless increased the number of new items on their shelves and increasingly relied on store associates to make consumers aware of those products.

CSNews 2011 Industry Forecast Study

Although the recession is officially over, consumers in the U.S. remain “mad as hell” and “frustrated” by the slow pace of recovery.



SUBSCRIBE TO E-NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIBE TO E-NEWSLETTER


Today's New Product


Curtis Gold Cup Brewer
Consistently reliable and priced to fit in any foodservice environment, the Curtis Gold Cup Brewer is a true "open source" machine that allows users to choose either grounds or pillow packs to brew a cup of coffee that meets the Specialty Coffee Association of America's Golden Cup standards, the company said.
Featured Videos

Loading...
Playlist

Related Videos
pie
Online Poll
» February 15, 2012
Which product categories do you intend to promote the most this year?
Vote / See Results
Stagnito Media
570 Lake Cook Rd, Suite 106
Deerfield IL 60015
Ph: 224-632-8200
Fax: 224-632-8266
Print / Electronic Media
Convenience Store News
CSNews for the Single Store Owner
Progressive Grocer
Progressive Grocer's Store Brands
The Gourmet Retailer
Retail Leader
Marketing Guidebook
Directory of Convenience Stores
Events
Hispanic Retail 360
Gourmet Insights Summit

Custom Media