Stagnito Media Convenienece Store News Convenienece Store News Single Store Owner Progressive Grocer The Gourmet Retailer Progressive Grocer Store Brands Retail Leader hispanic
 
Dec 11, 2012

Court Denies Request to Expedite Appeal in Swipe-Fee Settlement Case

PrintCourt Denies Request to Expedite Appeal in Swipe-Fee Settlement Case  

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit denied a request from Home Depot Inc. and other merchants to expedite the appeals process for the $7.25 billion settlement of the class-action swipe fee lawsuit against Visa Inc. and MasterCard Inc., the Associated Press reported.

The court stated it was deferring briefing for an appeal of the settlement until the preliminary deal receives final approval from the U.S. District Court in Brooklyn, where the litigation is currently pending. A ruling on final approval is expected next year, according to the news outlet.

"It offers little change to the anticompetitive practices of Visa and MasterCard, while it grants virtual immunity from future antitrust challenges for these financial services companies and their banking partners," a Home Depot spokesman said in response to the denial. "With that in mind, we have filed our objections with the court and continue to weigh our options with regard to the settlement."

As CSNews Online has reported in its ongoing coverage, the retail community has vocally opposed the proposed settlement since it was struck in July. The deal would end the seven-year class-action lawsuit that alleges that Visa and MasterCard, along with large banks that issue credit cards, conspired to set fees at arbitrarily high levels. The settlement would pay $6.05 billion to as many as eight million merchants, and temporarily reduce fees by $1.2 billion total.

Multiple retail and trade groups, including NACS, the Association for Convenience & Fuel Retailing, have objected to the settlement, stating that it would not introduce competition and transparency into the credit card swipe fee market.

"While we are disappointed with the ruling, we are very confident in our position and will be prepared to show at the final approval hearing that the settlement both violates due process and is plainly inadequate as a solution to the market failures that plague this industry," stated Jeff Shinder, a managing partner with Constantine Cannon LLP, which represents several of the named plaintiffs who joined in Home Depot's request for an expedited appeals process.

The decision to deny the request to expedite the appeals process was included in a letter filed in district court yesterday by attorneys who represent the class of merchants, the AP reported.








Find Reports & Data

CSNews’ 2013 Realities of the Aisle Consumer Study

When it comes to c-store shopper research, Convenience Store News' Realities of the Aisle is in a class by itself. .

CSNEWS 2013 INDUSTRY FORECAST STUDY

The 2013 Convenience Store News Industry Forecast Study projects a fairly optimistic view of business conditions for convenience store retailers this year despite the nation’s fiscal problems..

CSNEWS' 2012 TECHNOLOGY STUDY

A new crop of next-generation technology, including social media analysis, mobile payments and mobile applications (apps), is getting retailer attention, according to the Convenience Store News’ exclusive 2012 Technology Study..

CSNEWS 2012 FOODSERVICE STUDY

Nearly two-thirds of convenience store operators expect to see their foodservice sales increase this year compared to 2011, according to Convenience Store News’ exclusive 2012 Foodservice Study..

CSNEWS' 2012 INDUSTRY REPORT STUDY

The convenience store industry achieved several new sales peaks last year, but rising operations costs and continued volume declines in fuel and cigarettes made the climb difficult..

CSNEWS' 2012 REALITIES OF THE AISLE CONSUMER STUDY

When it comes to c-store consumer research, CSNews’ 2012 Realities of the Aisle is in a class by itself..



SUBSCRIBE TO E-NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIBE TO E-NEWSLETTER


ADVERTISEMENT
Product Spotlight


Bite Size, Big Flavor!
Introducing Cooked Perfect Bites - finger-friendly, delicious bite-size snacks designed specifically for the core Convenience Store consumer.
 
Featured Videos

Loading...
Playlist

Related Videos
Events + Webcasts
Participate in
LIVE and ON-DEMAND
presentations of
convenience store industry research
from your desktop.
Stagnito Media
570 Lake Cook Rd, Suite 310
Deerfield IL 60015
Ph: 224-632-8200
Fax: 224-632-8266

Privacy Policy
Print / Electronic Media
Convenience Store News
CSNews Supplier Guide
CSNews for the Single Store Owner
Progressive Grocer
Private Label ⇒ Store Brands
Independent Grocer Network
The Gourmet Retailer
Retail Leader
Marketing Guidebook
Directory of Convenience Stores
Events
Hispanic Retail 360

Custom Media